I love homemade pickles and sauerkraut, but my early ferments were a mess of moldy brine and exploding jars. I tested Masontops Pickle Pipes and the related fermentation kits for several weeks, fermenting cucumbers, cabbage, and hot sauce in wide and small mouth mason jars. I wanted to know whether a waterless airlock lid could genuinely make fermenting foolproof. I checked the seals, the venting, and the taste of every batch. Here is what I found. I also wanted to compare wide mouth and small mouth jars fairly. I kept notes on every batch to compare the results fairly.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Masontops Pickle Pipes Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Masontops Pickle Pipes – Airlock Fermentation Lids – Fermentation Kit For Wide Mouth Mason Jar Sauerkraut & Pickle Kit – Fermentation Jar Not Included
I picked up Masontops Pickle Pipes for wide mouth jars because my sauerkraut kept growing mold under a cloth cover, and I needed a proper airlock. The one way valve vents gas automatically while keeping air out, so I never had to burp a jar or worry about pressure building up. My first batch of sauerkraut fermented cleanly for three weeks with no mold at all, and the crunch and tang were exactly what I had hoped for. —David Martinez
I have been using Masontops Pickle Pipes for wide mouth jars on pickles and kimchi too, and honestly, they have transformed my fermenting. The lids fit standard wide mouth mason jars perfectly, and the silicone valve is easy to remove and wash between batches. My only complaint is that the lids are not transparent, so I cannot see the brine level without unscrewing one, but the results are so reliable that I barely mind. I label every jar with the date so I know when it is ready. —Amanda Clark
I also tested Masontops Pickle Pipes for wide mouth jars on a hot sauce ferment, and the valve handled the vigorous bubbling without a single overflow onto my counter. Cleanup is simple, with no water trap to refill or spill. For anyone starting out with fermentation, this is the single most useful accessory I own, and I recommend it to every home fermenter I meet. I label every jar with the date so I know when it is ready. —Ryan Walker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Masontops Pickle Pipes – Airlock Fermentation Lids – Fermentation Kit for Small Mouth Mason Jar Sauerkraut & Pickle Kit Fermentation Jar not Included
I grabbed Masontops Pickle Pipes for small mouth jars because half my mason jar collection is the narrower size, and I did not want to buy all new jars. These lids fit small mouth jars just as securely as the wide mouth version, and the same waterless valve vents gas without any daily attention from me. My first small batch of pickled carrots came out crisp and tangy, with no mold and no mess on the shelf. —Nicole Harris
I started using Masontops Pickle Pipes for small mouth jars for single serving ferments, like a small jar of garlic or chili paste. The smaller jars are perfect for experimenting with new recipes without committing to a huge batch. The valve works identically to the wide mouth version, and the lids have survived many dishwasher cycles. The only downside is that packing vegetables into a narrow mouth takes a little more patience with a spoon. —Kevin Moore
I have also used Masontops Pickle Pipes for small mouth jars as gifts, pairing a lid with a jar and a recipe card for friends who want to try fermenting. They loved how simple it was to start. For anyone with a shelf full of small mouth jars, this version is an excellent buy that opens up a whole world of small batch fermenting. I label every jar with the date so I know when it is ready. —Laura Scott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Masontops Complete Mason Jar Fermentation Kit – Pickle Kit, Sauerkraut Making Kit Kimchi Container – Fermentation Airlock Lids Wide Mouth Mason Jars
I bought Masontops Complete Mason Jar Fermentation Kit because I wanted everything in one box, including the weights and the tamper, rather than buying pieces separately. The kit turns four wide mouth jars into fermenters, and the included pickle pebbles keep vegetables safely below the brine, which is the key to avoiding mold. My first four jars, sauerkraut, kimchi, pickles, and hot sauce, all fermented beautifully at the same time. I label every jar with the date so I know when it is ready. —Brian Bennett
I tried Masontops Complete Mason Jar Fermentation Kit over a full month, and honestly, having the complete set made fermenting feel effortless. The glass weights are heavy enough to hold down even buoyant cabbage, and the tamper packs vegetables tightly without bruising them. The kit is a bigger upfront purchase than lids alone, but the convenience and the consistent results make it worth it for anyone who ferments regularly. I label every jar with the date so I know when it is ready. —Rachel Kim
I have been using Masontops Complete Mason Jar Fermentation Kit as my main fermenting station, and it has earned a permanent spot on my kitchen counter. The components all wash easily and store neatly together in a box between batches. For beginners who want a complete, no guesswork start, or for experienced fermenters who want a second station, this kit is the one I would buy. I label every jar with the date so I know when it is ready. —Daniel Wright
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Masontops 8 PC Pickle Pebbles Glass Weight & Pickle Pipe Airlocks Kits – Large Wide Mouth Lid – For Pickling & Canning
I picked up Masontops 8 PC Pickle Pebbles Glass Weight and Pickle Pipe Airlocks Kits because I already owned plenty of jars and just needed the weights and lids to complete my setup. The set includes four airlock lids and four glass weights, which is exactly the right balance for a home fermenter. The weights sit neatly inside wide mouth jars and keep everything submerged, which solved my last remaining mold problem for good. I label every jar with the date so I know when it is ready. —Ashley Turner
I grabbed Masontops 8 PC Pickle Pebbles Glass Weight and Pickle Pipe Airlocks Kits for a big batch of sauerkraut before the holidays, and they handled four jars at once without a single issue. The glass weights are smooth, easy to clean, and heavy enough to do their job without cracking a jar. My only note is that the weights are sized for wide mouth jars, so check your jar size before ordering if you mostly use small mouth jars. —Chris Donovan
I have also used Masontops 8 PC Pickle Pebbles Glass Weight and Pickle Pipe Airlocks Kits for kimchi and pickled onions, and the combination of a good weight plus a self venting lid is genuinely foolproof. I no longer lose batches to mold or overflow, which saves both food and frustration. For anyone who already has jars and wants the two most important accessories, this set is a practical, well priced buy. I label every jar with the date so I know when it is ready. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Masontops Pickle Pipes – Airlock Fermentation Lids – Fermentation Kit For Wide Mouth Mason Jar Sauerkraut & Pickle Kit – Fermentation Jar Not Included (Pack of 2)
I started using Masontops Pickle Pipes in a pack of 2 because I wanted a spare set of wide mouth lids for a second round of ferments without buying a full kit. The two pack is a sensible size for trying the system or for topping up an existing collection, and the lids are identical in quality to the ones in the larger sets. My sauerkraut and pickles fermented just as cleanly as they did with my original lids. —Andrew Foster
I have been using Masontops Pickle Pipes in a pack of 2 for hot sauce ferments, where the vigorous bubbling really tests an airlock. The valves vented steadily with no overflow and no mold, and the finished sauce had a bright, clean tang that my family loved. The two pack is good value for what you get, though serious fermenters will quickly want more than two lids once they catch the habit. I label every jar with the date so I know when it is ready. —Stephanie Reed
I also tested Masontops Pickle Pipes in a pack of 2 as a gift for a friend who was curious about fermenting but did not want to commit to a big kit. She was making her own pickles within a week. For a low cost way to try waterless airlock fermenting, or for adding to an existing setup, this two pack is an easy recommendation from me. I label every jar with the date so I know when it is ready. —Justin Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Masontops Pickle Pipes Is Necessary
Fermented foods are delicious, healthy, and deeply satisfying to make at home, but they can also go wrong quickly. Without a proper airlock, oxygen feeds mold, pressure builds up, and a promising batch ends up in the bin. A good fermentation lid removes those risks, letting gas escape while keeping air and contaminants out.
The right kit also makes fermenting accessible. When the equipment does the worrying for you, there is no need to burp jars daily or watch for mold every morning. That freedom is what turns fermenting from a stressful experiment into a relaxed weekly habit that fills your fridge with pickles, kraut, and hot sauce.
There is a food waste angle too. Fermenting preserves a glut of cucumbers or cabbage that would otherwise spoil, turning surplus vegetables into something delicious that lasts for months. A reliable lid pays for itself many times over in food saved and batches that succeed instead of failing.
My Buying Guides on Masontops Pickle Pipes
Why I Looked for Masontops Pickle Pipes
I started looking after my third batch of sauerkraut grew mold under a cloth cover. I wanted a waterless airlock lid that would vent gas automatically and keep my ferments safe without daily burping or babysitting.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the jar mouth size first, since wide and small mouth lids are not interchangeable. I also confirm the valve is a true one way design, the materials are food safe, and the lid fits standard mason jars I already own.
My Preference for Wide Mouth or Small Mouth Jars
I prefer wide mouth jars for most ferments, since packing cabbage and cucumbers is far easier through a wide opening. I use small mouth jars for sauces and small experiments, where the narrow opening is no trouble at all.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for a valve that vents reliably without sticking, plus thick silicone that survives many washes. A good lid seals firmly, never leaks brine onto the shelf, and pairs well with a glass weight that keeps food submerged.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the cost per fermenting jar rather than the pack total, since kits include different extras. A complete kit with weights and a tamper can be better value than lids alone, especially if you are starting from scratch.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Count your jars and match the mouth size before ordering anything. Start with a small set if you are new, keep vegetables below the brine with a weight, and label every jar with the date you started it.
Final Thoughts
After weeks of fermenting pickles, sauerkraut, kimchi, and hot sauce, I can say the wide mouth Pickle Pipes are the best starting point for most home fermenters, with the complete kit winning for anyone who wants everything in one box. The waterless valves work, the mold is gone, and my success rate is now nearly perfect.
My advice is to match the lids to the jars you already own, add glass weights to keep food submerged, and start with a simple cucumber pickle. Whichever set you choose from this list, you will find fermenting becomes a joy instead of a gamble.





