My whiskey kept turning watery before I finished the glass, so I went looking for a large ice cube tray that makes big, slow melting cubes. I tested five trays with filtered water, freezing batch after batch and timing how long the cubes lasted in a drink. Here is what I found, and which tray now lives in my freezer. I checked how easily the cubes released, how clear they froze, and how long they lasted in a drink, and I tried each tray in tumblers, bottles, and cocktail glasses to see which shapes suit which drinks.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Large Ice Cube Tray Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Samuelworld Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray Molds, 2-Pack, Big 2 Inch Cubes – Food Grade, Flexible, 8 Cavity Easy Release Slow Melting Ice for Whiskey, Cocktails, Gifts & Christmas – Black
I picked up the Samuelworld Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray Molds two pack because I wanted proper two inch cubes for whiskey, and these delivered exactly that. Each tray makes eight big cubes that release with a gentle twist, no cracking or prying, and the food grade silicone feels thick and sturdy. The cubes come out clear and solid, and they keep a drink cold for a full evening without watering it down. —Rachel Kim
What I like most about the Samuelworld Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray Molds is how practical the two pack is. One tray freezes while the other serves, so I never run out during a gathering, and the lids keep freezer smells away from the ice. The trays stack neatly, fill without spilling, and the black silicone looks smart on a bar cart. The lids keep freezer smells away, and the trays stack neatly in a crowded freezer. —Daniel Wright
I have been using the Samuelworld Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray Molds for several weeks now, and honestly, they are the trays I would buy again first. The cubes melt slowly, the release is effortless, and the two pack covers a whole evening of cocktails. For anyone who drinks whiskey or cocktails at home, this is my top pick. For anyone who drinks whiskey or cocktails at home, this two pack is my top pick. —Ashley Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Ice Cube Tray, Mikiwon 2 inch Rose Ice Cube Trays With Covers, 3 Cavity Silicone Rose Ice Tray & 3 Diamond Ice Ball Maker, Easy Release Large Ice Cube Form for Chilled Cocktails, Whiskey Juice Black
I tried the Ice Cube Tray from Mikiwon because I wanted ice that looks as good as it tastes, and the rose and diamond shapes are genuinely beautiful in a glass. The silicone tray makes three rose cubes and three diamond balls, all two inches across, and they release easily with a light push from below. The included lids keep the trays stackable and the ice free of freezer odors. —Chris Donovan
What stood out about the Ice Cube Tray from Mikiwon was how long the shapes lasted in a drink. A rose cube in a cocktail stayed solid through a full conversation, and the diamond balls look stunning in a whiskey glass. The tray itself is sturdy, fills without spilling, and the shapes come out crisp and detailed rather than blobby. The shapes come out crisp and detailed, and they make any drink look special. —Melissa Grant
My honest take on the Ice Cube Tray from Mikiwon is that it is the prettiest tray in this group, with one limit: three cavities per shape means a smaller batch than the square trays. For a dinner party where presentation matters, it is wonderful. For a big gathering, buy two trays or pair it with the Samuelworld set above. For a dinner party where presentation matters, this tray is wonderful. —Andrew Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray for 20-30-40 oz Tumbler Cup, Slow Melting Ice Mold with Lid, Easy Release Ice Maker(Grey)
I picked up the Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray for 20-30-40 oz Tumbler Cup because my large tumbler needed ice that actually fits. The cylinder mold makes a tall, slow melting column of ice that slides into a big tumbler and keeps iced coffee cold for hours without diluting it. The grey silicone is thick and flexible, and the lid stops spills on the way to the freezer. The grey silicone is thick and flexible, and the lid stops spills on the way to the freezer. —Stephanie Reed
What I like about the Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray for 20-30-40 oz Tumbler Cup is how well the cylinder fits. It slides into my forty ounce tumbler with room to spare, and the ice lasts through a whole work morning. Release is easy: a gentle squeeze pops the column out intact. For iced coffee and cold brew, this is the tray I reach for most. For iced coffee and cold brew, this is the tray I reach for most mornings. —Justin Cole
My honest take on the Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray for 20-30-40 oz Tumbler Cup is that it is a specialist tray, not a general cocktail tray, and you should buy it for tumblers and large cups. If you mostly drink from a big insulated tumbler, it is excellent. If you want cubes for whiskey glasses, pick one of the square trays above instead. If you mostly drink from a big insulated tumbler, it is an excellent choice. —Hannah Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Long Ice Cube Molds 2 Pack Silicone Big Large Ice Cubes Trays Blocks Sticks with Lids Stackable and Easy-Release for Water Bottles,Bottled Beverage,Sodas
I tried the Long Ice Cube Molds 2 Pack Silicone Big Large Ice Cubes Trays Blocks Sticks because my water bottles needed ice that fits through a narrow neck. These long stick molds make slim ice that slides straight into a bottle and keeps water cold for hours. The two pack means I always have a batch ready, and the lids let the trays stack flat in the freezer. The two pack means I always have a batch ready, and the lids let the trays stack flat. —Tyler Bennett
I have been using the Long Ice Cube Molds 2 Pack Silicone Big Large Ice Cubes Trays Blocks Sticks all summer, and honestly, they are the only trays I own that suit a water bottle. The sticks release easily with a bend of the tray, they do not crack or splinter, and the silicone feels sturdy enough to last. For gym bags, hikes, and long drives, they are brilliant. For gym bags, hikes, and long drives, these stick molds are brilliant. —Olivia Grant
One fair note about the Long Ice Cube Molds 2 Pack Silicone Big Large Ice Cubes Trays Blocks Sticks is that stick ice suits bottles, not cocktail glasses, where it looks odd and melts faster than a big cube. Buy these for bottles and tumblers, and keep a square tray for whiskey. For their intended job, though, they are the best I tested. For their intended job, they are the best trays I tested. —Nathan Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – 2Pack Big Square Old Fashioned Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky
I grabbed the Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid for old fashioned cocktails, because I wanted proper two inch square cubes with a lid. The two pack makes big, clear cubes that release with a twist, and the lids keep the trays stackable and the ice clean. In a whiskey glass, the cubes look the part and melt slowly enough to last a full drink. —Sarah Mitchell
What I like about the Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid is the value: two trays, lids included, at a friendly price. The silicone is flexible without feeling flimsy, and the cubes come out with sharp edges rather than rounded mush. For a home bar on a budget, it covers the basics well. The silicone is flexible without feeling flimsy, and the cubes come out with sharp edges. —James Carter
My honest take on the Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid is that it is a solid budget alternative to my top pick, with one small trade off: the cubes freeze slightly cloudier than the Samuelworld set. In a dark spirit you will never notice. If price matters more than perfect clarity, this two pack is a smart buy. If price matters more than perfect clarity, this two pack is a smart buy. —Emily Rodriguez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Large Ice Cube Tray Is Necessary
I started looking for a large ice cube tray after one too many whiskeys turned watery before I had finished the first glass. Small cubes from a standard tray melt fast, dilute the drink, and leave you with lukewarm spirits. A large cube melts slowly, keeps the drink cold, and looks far better in the glass, so the upgrade felt worth trying.
The market is full of trays that promise big cubes and then deliver flimsy silicone that spills in the freezer or refuses to release the ice. I wanted trays that fill cleanly, freeze flat, pop out easily, and survive daily use without tearing. Size mattered too: a true two inch cube is very different from a slightly larger than normal one.
I tested each tray by freezing multiple batches with filtered water, checking how easily the cubes released, how clear they froze, and how long they lasted in a drink. I also tried them in tumblers, bottles, and cocktail glasses to see which shapes suit which drinks. Here are the five trays I tested, and the ones I would buy again.
My Buying Guides on Large Ice Cube Tray
Why I Looked for Large Ice Cube Tray
My drinks were watery before I finished them, because small ice cubes melt in minutes. I wanted large, slow melting cubes that keep a drink cold without diluting it.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the cube size, the silicone quality, and whether a lid is included to stop freezer smells. I also look for easy release, a stable base, and a tray that stacks neatly.
My Preference for Square or Round Ice
I prefer big square cubes for whiskey and cocktails because they melt slowly and look classic. Round ice suits a tumbler, and long sticks are made for water bottles.
What I Look for in Quality
Good silicone is thick, food grade, and flexible enough to pop cubes out without a fight. I also want a tray that sits flat, fills without spilling, and does not absorb freezer odors.
How I Compare Prices
I compare by cost per cube and by whether the listing is a one pack or a two pack. A two pack that covers a full evening is better value than a single tray that leaves you short.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Pick big square cubes for cocktails, a tumbler mold for large cups, and long sticks for bottles. Freeze with filtered water, keep the tray level, and store finished cubes in a bag to free the tray.
Final Thoughts
After freezing dozens of batches across all five trays, the Samuelworld two pack is my clear favorite for big, slow melting cubes, with the Mikiwon rose tray close behind for anyone who wants pretty ice for cocktails. The tumbler mold is the pick for large cups, and the long stick trays are perfect for water bottles.
My advice is to fill trays with filtered water and freeze them flat, then pop the cubes out and store them in a bag so the tray is free for the next batch. Big cubes melt slower and dilute drinks less, and once you try them, small cloudy cubes will feel like a compromise.





