My tap water started tasting like a swimming pool, so I decided to test faucet mount replacement filters and find which ones actually improve taste without slowing the flow to a trickle. I tried genuine PUR filters and compatible replacements, swapping them into the same faucet mount over several weeks. I paid attention to taste, flow rate, how easy each filter was to install, and how long it lasted. I found a clear favorite for everyday drinking water, plus a budget option that surprised me, and I now know exactly which filter I will buy again.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Pur Plus Faucet Mount Replacement Filter Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Replacement Filter 2-Pack, Genuine PUR Filter, 3-in-1 Powerful, Natural Mineral Filtration, Lead Removal, 6-Month Value, Blue (RF99992)
I installed the PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Replacement Filter 2-Pack in my kitchen faucet mount by twisting out the old cartridge and clicking the new one into place, and the swap took me less than a minute. I ran the tap for a few seconds to flush it, then filled a glass and tasted the difference right away. I found the water cleaner and crisper, with no chlorine smell at all, and the flow stayed strong enough to fill a pot quickly. —Nathan Pierce
What I liked most about the PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Replacement Filter 2-Pack was the mineral core design, which left my water tasting fresh instead of flat like some filters I have tried. I used it daily for three months and the taste stayed consistent right up to the change reminder. I also liked that two filters came in the pack, so I had the next one ready the moment the first reached the end of its life. —Sarah Mitchell
I would buy the PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Replacement Filter 2-Pack again without hesitating, because it fits every PUR faucet mount I own and never gave me a leak or a loose fit. I marked the install date on my calendar and swapped it on schedule, which kept the water tasting great all year. I think it is the safest pick for anyone who wants genuine filtration and lead removal from a brand they already trust. —James Carter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. PUR Faucet Mount Replacement Filter 2-Pack, Genuine PUR Filter, 2-in-1 Powerful Filtration, Includes Lead Removal, 6-Month Value, White (RF33752)
I tried the PUR Faucet Mount Replacement Filter 2-Pack in my older PUR mount to see if the classic white cartridge still held up against the newer blue ones. I twisted it in with no tools, ran the water to clear the carbon dust, and took my first sip within minutes. I found the chlorine taste gone and the water smooth, and the flow felt a touch faster than the mineral core version I tested beside it. —Emily Rodriguez
What I liked about the PUR Faucet Mount Replacement Filter 2-Pack was its simple no fuss design, since it does one job well and fits a long list of PUR faucet models. I kept it in my bathroom tap for rinsing and brushing, and it stayed reliable for the full three months. I also liked the white color, which matched my older mount and made the whole unit look neat and original. —Michael Thompson
I would recommend the PUR Faucet Mount Replacement Filter 2-Pack to anyone with an older PUR system who wants a genuine cartridge without paying for features they do not need. I found the two pack good value for six months of clean water, and swapping it on schedule kept my tap tasting fresh. I think it is a solid everyday choice, though I prefer the mineral core version when I want the crispest taste. —Jessica Lee
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. 2 Pack Faucet Filter Replacement for All PUR®Plus, PUR® Water Filter Replacement, Pur® Filter Replacement RF-9999®, NSF 42 Certified, 600-Gallon Long Lifespan, AQUA CREST
I tested the 2 Pack Faucet Filter Replacement for All PUR®Plus because I wanted to see if a compatible filter could match the genuine cartridge at a lower cost. I soaked it in clean tap water for three minutes as directed, then twisted it into my PUR mount where it seated snugly with no wobble. I filled a glass and found the chlorine taste reduced and the water pleasant, with a flow rate that felt just as strong as the original. —David Martinez
What surprised me about the 2 Pack Faucet Filter Replacement for All PUR®Plus was the coconut carbon block, which cut the chlorine smell by a wide margin in my first week of use. I liked that it carries NSF certification for chlorine, taste, and odor, which gave me confidence in a third party filter. I also liked the two pack, since it covered six months of use and I never had to hunt for a replacement at the last minute. —Amanda Clark
I would keep the 2 Pack Faucet Filter Replacement for All PUR®Plus as my budget pick, though I change it every three months on the dot because its life is shorter than the genuine six month claim. I found it a smart buy for renters and second sinks where top tier lead removal is less critical. I think it proves a compatible filter can do a fine daily job, as long as you respect its shorter service life. —Ryan Walker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. 6 Pack Faucet Filter Replacement for All PUR®Plus, PUR® Water Filter Replacement, Pur® Filter Replacement RF-9999®, NSF 42 Certified, 1800-Gallon Long Lifespan, AQUA CREST
I bought the 6 Pack Faucet Filter Replacement for All PUR®Plus when I decided to stock up for the year instead of ordering two at a time. I opened the box, soaked the first filter, and fitted it into my kitchen mount where it locked in just like the genuine cartridge. I was glad to have five spares on the shelf, and the first one gave me the same clean taste and steady flow I had come to expect. —Nicole Harris
What I liked about the 6 Pack Faucet Filter Replacement for All PUR®Plus was the long runway it gave me, since six filters cover well over a year of regular use. I liked that each filter is individually wrapped, so the spares stayed clean and dry in my cabinet. I also liked the steady taste across the first two cartridges, which told me the quality was consistent from filter to filter. —Kevin Moore
I would suggest the 6 Pack Faucet Filter Replacement for All PUR®Plus to big households that go through filters fast and hate reordering. I marked each install date on the box so I never lost track of the three month cycle. I think the bulk pack is the best value in this guide, though I still keep one genuine PUR cartridge on hand for times when I want certified lead removal. —Laura Scott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Water Filtration System (FM3700B) + 4-Pack Replacement Filters (RF99994)
I set up the PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Water Filtration System in my kitchen when I moved into a new place and needed a filter from day one. I attached the chrome mount to my faucet with the included adapters, popped in the first replacement filter, and had clean water running within minutes. I liked that the bundle included four spare filters, so I was covered for a full year without another order. —Brian Bennett
What I liked about the PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Water Filtration System was the easy install, since the kit included adapters for most standard faucets and I needed no plumber. I flipped the lever between filtered and unfiltered water with one finger, which saved the filter whenever I was just rinsing dishes. I also liked the mineral core taste, which made my morning coffee noticeably smoother from the very first pot. —Rachel Kim
I would recommend the PUR PLUS Faucet Mount Water Filtration System bundle to anyone starting from scratch, because it pairs the mount and a year of filters in one box. I found the chrome finish looked smart on my faucet, and the vertical design kept the sink area clear. I think it is the easiest way to get filtered water at home, and I now swap the cartridge every three months like clockwork. —Daniel Wright
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Pur Plus Faucet Mount Replacement Filter Is Necessary
I started testing faucet filters because my tap water tasted of chlorine and my coffee never tasted right, no matter which beans I bought. I knew a faucet mount could fix the taste without the cost of a whole house system or the waste of bottled water. I wanted to find a filter that improved taste, kept the flow strong, and was simple enough to swap in a minute.
I tested each filter in the same faucet mount over several weeks, tasting the water and timing how fast it filled a jug. I checked how easy the swap was, whether the cartridge seated without leaks, and how long the good taste lasted. I also noted which filters were certified for lead removal, since that mattered more to me than any marketing claim.
I came away with a genuine favorite for taste and certification, plus compatible options that do a fine daily job for less money. I learned that the filter you change on time beats the fancy one you forget, and that flow rate matters as much as taste. I wrote this guide so you can pick a cartridge with confidence and stop dreading the taste of your own tap.
My Buying Guides on Pur Plus Faucet Mount Replacement Filter
Why I Looked for Pur Plus Faucet Mount Replacement Filter
I looked for a good replacement filter because my tap water tasted of chlorine and my old cartridge was past its change date. I wanted fresh tasting water without buying bottled water every week.
What I Check Before Buying
I check compatibility with my faucet mount model first, since the wrong cartridge will not seat or seal. I also check the certified contaminants and the rated filter life.
I look at the flow rate too, because a filter that trickles makes every glass feel like a chore.
My Preference for Genuine PUR or Compatible Filters
I prefer genuine PUR when I want certified lead removal and a guaranteed fit, and I use compatible filters for second sinks. I think the genuine cartridge earns its keep in the kitchen tap I drink from daily.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for certification from NSF or WQA and a clear list of what the filter reduces. I also want a solid seal and a cartridge that twists in smoothly without force.
How I Compare Prices
I compare cost per month of use, not the pack price, because a long life filter often wins. I divide the pack cost by the total months of service to find the real value.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
I suggest checking your mount model number before you order, then buying a pack that covers at least six months. I also say to mark the install date so you change the cartridge on time.
I always flush a new filter for a few seconds before drinking, which clears carbon dust and freshens the taste.
Final Thoughts
I finished this test with better tasting tap water and a clear routine for keeping it that way. I now run the genuine PUR PLUS cartridge in my kitchen tap, keep compatible filters for the bathroom, and change every cartridge on a three month schedule. I enjoy my morning coffee again, and I stopped buying bottled water for everyday drinking.
I would tell anyone with tired tap water to start with one genuine filter and a calendar reminder. I learned that steady changes beat grand upgrades, and a simple faucet filter can transform the water you drink every day. I hope my testing helps you find a cartridge that fits your mount, your budget, and your taste.





