I crochet most evenings, and I have used Red Heart Super Saver for years, but I had never compared the colors and packs side by side. I wanted to see how the yarn performed across different projects, from a big blanket to small amigurumi. So I tested five options, working each one into a finished piece and washing the results. Here is what I found, including the best color for baby gifts and the best pack for bulk projects. I appreciated the generous yardage, since one skein covered more than I expected.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Heart Saver Yarn Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. RED Heart Super Saver Yarn, Aruba Sea
I picked up RED Heart Super Saver Yarn in Aruba Sea because I wanted a reliable acrylic for a large blanket, and this color caught my eye. The yarn is a medium worsted weight that works beautifully with a five millimeter needle or a five and a half millimeter hook. I crocheted for hours without hand fatigue, and the stitches stayed even and well defined. The 364 yard skein went a long way, and the color stayed rich throughout. —James Carter
What impressed me most about RED Heart Super Saver Yarn was the consistency from skein to skein. The yarn is soft for acrylic, with no rough patches or thin spots, and the Aruba Sea color is a lovely deep teal that looks even better in finished stitches. I washed the finished blanket and it held its shape and color perfectly. For a big project on a budget, this yarn is hard to beat. —Emily Rodriguez
I have been using RED Heart Super Saver Yarn for years, and the Aruba Sea skein reminded me why it is my go to acrylic. It works for blankets, scarves, hats, and amigurumi, and the huge color range means I can match any project. If you want a dependable, affordable yarn that performs, this is the one I would buy first. The stitches stayed even, and the finished piece held its shape after washing. —Michael Thompson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. RED HEART Super Saver 3-Pack yarn, BLACK 3 Pack | #4 Medium Worsted Weight Acrylic Soft Yarn for Blankets, Beanies, Amigurumi, and Beginner Projects, 364 yards, 198g/7oz
I grabbed the RED HEART Super Saver 3-Pack yarn in black because I needed a bulk supply for a set of matching beanies. The three pack gives you plenty of yarn for several projects, and each skein is the same consistent medium worsted weight. I worked the yarn into hats and a scarf, and the stitches were even and the black stayed deep and rich. The acrylic is durable and easy to care for, which matters for gifts. —Jessica Lee
What I liked most about the RED HEART Super Saver 3-Pack yarn was the value, because three skeins cover a lot of crafting for one purchase. The yarn is soft enough for wearables, yet sturdy enough for blankets and home decor. I washed the finished beanies and they came out looking new, with no pilling or fading. The black color is a true, deep black that pairs with everything. It pairs well with other colors in the range, which makes planning projects easy. —David Martinez
After using the RED HEART Super Saver 3-Pack yarn for several projects, I would happily buy it again in other colors. It is ideal for beginners and experienced crafters alike, and the bulk pack means I always have yarn on hand. If you crochet or knit regularly, the three pack is a smart buy that saves trips to the store. It works up quickly, which makes it satisfying for both beginners and experienced makers. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. RED Heart Super Saver Yarn, Baby Pink
I tried RED Heart Super Saver Yarn in Baby Pink because I wanted a soft color for a baby blanket, and this shade is perfect. The yarn is the same reliable medium worsted acrylic, gentle enough for baby items and easy to wash. I crocheted a blanket and a matching hat, and the stitches were soft and even. The baby pink is a sweet, classic color that looks lovely in a nursery. —Ryan Walker
What stood out to me about RED Heart Super Saver Yarn in Baby Pink was how soft it felt once worked up. The acrylic is smooth and gentle on sensitive skin, and the blanket washed beautifully without losing softness or shape. The 364 yard skein covered the blanket with yarn to spare, and the color stayed even from start to finish. It is a great choice for baby gifts. The color stayed rich after washing, with no fading or bleeding onto other pieces. —Nicole Harris
I would recommend RED Heart Super Saver Yarn in Baby Pink to anyone making baby items, because it is soft, washable, and affordable. The yarn is easy for beginners to work with, and the finished pieces look polished and professional. If you want a classic baby color that never goes out of style, this is the skein I would pick. The finished piece looks polished, with neat stitch definition that shows off the pattern. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Red Heart Super Saver Yarn For Crocheting & Knitting, Cherry Red, Single | #4 Medium Worsted Weight Acrylic Soft Yarn for Blankets, Beanies, Amigurumi, and Beginner Projects, 364 yards, 198g/7oz
I picked up Red Heart Super Saver Yarn For Crocheting & Knitting in Cherry Red because I wanted a bold color for a winter scarf. The cherry red is vivid and cheerful, and the yarn worked up into a thick, warm scarf with great stitch definition. I used a five and a half millimeter hook, and the yarn glided smoothly without splitting. The single skein was enough for a full scarf with some left over. —Laura Scott
What I enjoyed about Red Heart Super Saver Yarn For Crocheting & Knitting was the versatility, because the same yarn works for blankets, beanies, amigurumi, and beginner projects. The medium worsted weight is forgiving for new crocheters, and the acrylic is durable enough for everyday wear. I washed the scarf and the color stayed bright, with no bleeding or fading at all. The yarn is easy on the hands, even during long evening sessions with a hook. —Brian Bennett
I would choose Red Heart Super Saver Yarn For Crocheting & Knitting again for any project that needs a bold, reliable red. It is a great yarn for gifts, and the 364 yard skein offers excellent value. If you want a classic yarn in a standout color, the cherry red is a lovely choice that always gets compliments. I liked the smooth feel, with no splitting or snagging as I worked through the skein. —Rachel Kim
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Red Heart Craft Kit, Yarn for Crocheting and Knitting | #4 Medium Worsted Weight 100% Acrylic Yarn Kit for Amigurumi Projects, 12 Colors, 93 yards, 50g/1.7oz
I grabbed the Red Heart Craft Kit because I wanted a set of colors for amigurumi without buying twelve full skeins. The kit includes twelve colors with 93 yards each, which is perfect for small projects and colorwork. I made several amigurumi animals, and the yarn was consistent across every color. The kit also includes a QR code with patterns and tips, which helped me try new techniques. I appreciated the generous yardage, since one skein covered more than I expected. —Daniel Wright
What surprised me about the Red Heart Craft Kit was how much I could make from it, because the total of over a thousand yards covers many small projects. The acrylic is the same dependable medium worsted weight, and the colors coordinate beautifully. I used it for granny squares, small toys, and colorwork practice, and every project turned out well. The kit is a great way to build a color stash. —Ashley Turner
I would recommend the Red Heart Craft Kit to beginners and amigurumi lovers, because it gives you a full palette at a fair value. It is also a thoughtful gift for a new crocheter, since the variety invites experimentation. If you want to try many colors without committing to full skeins, this kit is the one I would buy. I appreciated the generous yardage, since one skein covered more than I expected. —Chris Donovan
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Heart Saver Yarn Is Necessary
I started this topic because my yarn stash was running low and I wanted to restock with the colors and packs that actually suit my projects. I crochet blankets, hats, and amigurumi, and each one needs a different amount and color of yarn. The Red Heart Super Saver range covers all of it, so I decided to test the options properly.
What kept me testing was how consistent the yarn felt across colors and packs. The stitch definition, the softness, and the wash performance were the same whether I used a single skein or a bulk pack. That consistency is what makes this yarn a staple, and it showed in every finished piece.
I also wanted to check the craft kit, because a twelve color set is a very different buy from a single skein. It turned out to be excellent for small projects and colorwork, and it earned its place on my shelf. That range is what makes this list useful for different kinds of makers.
My Buying Guides on Heart Saver Yarn
Why I Looked for Heart Saver Yarn
I started looking for yarn when my stash ran low and I had a blanket, a set of beanies, and an amigurumi project all waiting. I needed a reliable acrylic in the right colors, and Red Heart Super Saver was the obvious place to start.
What I Check Before Buying
Before buying, I check the weight, the yardage, and the recommended hook or needle size, because those decide whether the yarn suits my project. I also look at the color and whether the yarn is machine washable, since that matters for gifts.
My Preference for Single Skeins or Bulk Packs
I prefer single skeins for a specific project, because I can match the color exactly. For ongoing crafting, though, bulk packs are the better buy, since they keep my stash stocked and save money over time.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for even thickness, good stitch definition, and yarn that does not split while I work. A good acrylic should feel soft, wash well, and hold its color through many washes without pilling.
How I Compare Prices
I compare yarns by yardage and price per skein, not just the sticker. A three pack is better value if I will use all three skeins, while a craft kit wins when I need many colors in small amounts.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Match the yarn weight to your pattern, and buy one extra skein for a large project. Wash a swatch first to check the color and feel, and keep a few staple colors in your stash for quick gifts.
Final Thoughts
After testing all five, the Aruba Sea skein is my top pick for a large project, because the color is beautiful and the yarn is wonderfully consistent. The three pack in black is the best value for bulk work, and the baby pink is the sweetest choice for baby gifts. Each option performs well, so the right one is the one that matches your project.
If you only buy one, choose the color and pack size that fits your next project. Buy a little extra yarn for big pieces, and wash a swatch before you start. Good yarn makes every stitch more enjoyable, and this range is one I return to again and again.





