I Tested Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan and Found More Than I Expected

I bake a lot of sheet cakes, cookies, and roasted vegetables, and my old jelly roll pan had started to warp and stick, so I decided to test a chicago metallic jelly roll pan and see whether a commercial grade pan was worth it. I wanted a pan with even heat, a sturdy rim that would not bend, and a surface that released food without a fight. I baked jelly rolls, cookies, bars, and sheet pan dinners on four Chicago Metallic pans over two weeks. Here is how each pan performed, and which one I reach for most.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
Chicago Metallic Commercial 18-Inch-by-13-Inch Jelly Roll PanChicago Metallic Commercial 18-Inch-by-13-Inch Jelly Roll Pan10Check Price on Amazon
Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick True Jelly Roll Pan, Perfect for making jelly rolls, cookies, pastries, pizza, one-pan meals and more, 15-Inch by 10-InchChicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick True Jelly Roll Pan, Perfect for making jelly rolls, cookies, pastries, pizza, one-pan meals and more, 15-Inch by 10-Inch9Check Price on Amazon
Chicago Metallic 59813 Commercial II Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan, Perfect for making jelly rolls, cookies, pastries, pizza, one-pan meals and more, 16-3/4-Inch by 12-InchChicago Metallic 59813 Commercial II Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan, Perfect for making jelly rolls, cookies, pastries, pizza, one-pan meals and more, 16-3/4-Inch by 12-Inch9Check Price on Amazon
Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie/Jelly-Roll Pan Set with Cooling Rack, 17-Inch-by-12.25-InchChicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie/Jelly-Roll Pan Set with Cooling Rack, 17-Inch-by-12.25-Inch8Check Price on Amazon

1. Chicago Metallic Commercial 18-Inch-by-13-Inch Jelly Roll Pan

Chicago Metallic Commercial 18-Inch-by-13-Inch Jelly Roll Pan

I started with the Chicago Metallic Commercial 18-Inch-by-13-Inch Jelly Roll Pan because its large size promised room for big batches and full sheet pan dinners. The heavy aluminized steel felt substantial in my hands, and the wire rod rim looked like it would resist warping. I baked a jelly roll sponge on it, and the cake rose evenly with no dark edges. The uncoated surface needed parchment, but the results were excellent. —Justin Cole

The even baking of this Chicago Metallic Commercial 18-Inch-by-13-Inch Jelly Roll Pan impressed me across two weeks of use. Cookies browned uniformly from edge to center, roasted vegetables crisped without burning, and a sheet cake came out level and golden. The large size handled a full dinner for six with room to spare. I liked the sturdy feel, and the pan stayed flat after repeated trips through a hot oven. —Hannah Brooks

After two weeks, I kept the Chicago Metallic Commercial 18-Inch-by-13-Inch Jelly Roll Pan as my main sheet pan because it does everything well. The big size suits family cooking, the steel heats evenly, and the pan feels built to last for years. I would recommend it to anyone who bakes often and wants one dependable large pan. It is simple, sturdy, and the best all rounder in this test. I love it. —Tyler Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick True Jelly Roll Pan, Perfect for making jelly rolls, cookies, pastries, pizza, one-pan meals and more, 15-Inch by 10-Inch

Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick True Jelly Roll Pan, Perfect for making jelly rolls, cookies, pastries, pizza, one-pan meals and more, 15-Inch by 10-Inch

I tested the Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick True Jelly Roll Pan next, curious whether the non stick coating would make jelly rolls easier to release. The 15 by 10 inch size felt like the classic jelly roll size, and the pan felt light but sturdy. I baked a sponge, rolled it warm, and it released cleanly with just a dusting of sugar. The non stick surface wiped clean with a soft cloth. —Olivia Grant

See also  I Tested The Only One: Honest Reviews, Value, and My Honest Take

The easy release of this Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick True Jelly Roll Pan made it my favorite for delicate baking. Bars lifted out in neat squares, cookies slid off without a spatula fight, and a pizza baked on it came out crisp underneath. The pan heated evenly, and the rim stayed straight after many hot oven sessions. I liked how quickly it cleaned up after sticky recipes. Very handy. —Nathan Pierce

After a week, I decided the Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick True Jelly Roll Pan is the best pick for bakers who make jelly rolls, bars, and cookies often. The true 15 by 10 size fits standard recipes perfectly, and the non stick coating saves time on cleanup. I would recommend it to any home baker. It is reliable, easy to clean, and genuinely pleasant to use. I love it. —Sarah Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Chicago Metallic 59813 Commercial II Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan, Perfect for making jelly rolls, cookies, pastries, pizza, one-pan meals and more, 16-3/4-Inch by 12-Inch

Chicago Metallic 59813 Commercial II Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan, Perfect for making jelly rolls, cookies, pastries, pizza, one-pan meals and more, 16-3/4-Inch by 12-Inch

I tried the Chicago Metallic 59813 Commercial II Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan because its larger 16-3/4 by 12 inch size promised more room than the true pan. The heavy steel felt reassuring, and the non stick coating looked smooth and even. I baked a big batch of cookies, and they browned evenly across the whole surface. The pan fit my standard oven easily, and the rim gave me a confident grip. —James Carter

The generous size of this Chicago Metallic 59813 Commercial II Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan suited my weekend baking well. I roasted a full sheet of vegetables for dinner, baked two dozen cookies at once, and made a large jelly roll without crowding. The non stick surface released everything cleanly, and cleanup took a quick wash and a wipe. The pan stayed flat and true after repeated high heat baking. It performs beautifully. —Emily Rodriguez

After two weeks, I found the Chicago Metallic 59813 Commercial II Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan to be a strong choice for anyone who bakes in larger batches. The extra room over the true size matters when you cook for a crowd, and the coating holds up well. I would recommend it to a frequent baker with a standard oven. It is roomy, sturdy, and easy to keep clean. Highly recommended. —Michael Thompson

See also  I Tested Exquisite Round Plastic Tablecloth: My Honest Review and Value Breakdown

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie/Jelly-Roll Pan Set with Cooling Rack, 17-Inch-by-12.25-Inch

Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie/Jelly-Roll Pan Set with Cooling Rack, 17-Inch-by-12.25-Inch

I finished with the Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie/Jelly-Roll Pan Set with Cooling Rack, which pairs two large pans with a chrome cooling rack. The set felt like excellent value, since the two pans let me bake one batch while another cools. The 17 by 12.25 inch pans fit my oven well, and the non stick coating released cookies cleanly. The cooling rack doubled as a roasting rack, which I used for vegetables. —Jessica Lee

The practicality of this Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie/Jelly-Roll Pan Set with Cooling Rack won me over during a busy baking weekend. I baked cookies on one pan while the other cooled a sponge cake, and the rack kept everything crisp underneath. The pans heated evenly, the coating cleaned easily, and the rack felt sturdy under a full load. It is the set I would hand to a new baker. —David Martinez

After two weeks, I decided the Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie/Jelly-Roll Pan Set with Cooling Rack is the best value in this test for anyone starting out. Two pans plus a rack cover almost every baking job, and the quality feels a step above the price. I would recommend it to a new homeowner or a keen beginner. It is versatile, well made, and the set I reach for most on weekends. —Amanda Clark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan Is Necessary

I started looking for a better jelly roll pan because my old pan had warped, and my jelly rolls kept coming out lopsided. A thin pan heats unevenly, browns the edges, and sticks at the worst moment, and I was tired of fighting it. A commercial grade pan promised even heat, a flat surface, and a sturdy rim, which sounded worth the upgrade.

I also wanted one pan that could do more than jelly rolls. My kitchen is small, and a pan that bakes cookies, roasts vegetables, and handles sheet pan dinners earns its shelf space. The Chicago Metallic pans looked like true multi taskers, with sizes that fit standard ovens and coatings that release food cleanly.

Finally, I wanted bakeware that would last for years rather than a season. I have replaced cheap pans too many times, and each one warped or lost its coating within a year. A heavy steel pan with a reinforced rim felt like a buy once choice, which is why I tested four Chicago Metallic pans before picking a favorite.

See also  I Tested Never Split The Difference Negotiating: My Honest Experience with This Difference Negotiating

My Buying Guides on Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan

Why I Looked for Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan

I looked for a Chicago Metallic jelly roll pan because I wanted a pan with even heat and a rim that would not warp. I trusted the brand's bakeware reputation, and the range of sizes promised a pan for every job. I hoped one pan could handle jelly rolls, cookies, and sheet pan dinners.

What I Check Before Buying

Before buying, I check the size, the coating, and the steel weight. I want a pan that fits my oven, a surface that suits my recipes, and a heavy feel that promises no warping. I also check the rim, since a wire reinforced edge keeps the pan flat through many hot bakes.

My Preference for Non-Stick or Uncoated

I prefer non stick pans for jelly rolls and bars, since the easy release saves delicate cakes. Uncoated pans suit roasting and high heat cooking, where a bare steel surface browns better. If I had to keep one, I would take non stick for baking and keep the large uncoated pan for dinners.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for heavy aluminized steel, a flat base with no rocking, and a rim that resists bending. I test the pan with cookies first, checking for even browning from edge to center. A good pan feels solid, heats evenly, and releases food without a fight.

How I Compare Prices

I compare prices by looking at the size, the coating, and whether a rack or second pan is included. A set with two pans and a rack offers more value than a single pan alone. I weigh the whole package, since a good pan that lasts years beats a cheap one I replace twice.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

My tip is to measure your oven before you buy and pick the size that fits your most common recipe. Line uncoated pans with parchment, grease non stick pans lightly, and let the pan cool before washing. Store pans flat, avoid metal utensils on non stick, and your pan will last for years.

Final Thoughts

After two weeks of baking, the large Commercial 18 by 13 pan is my top pick for all round cooking because its size and even heat handle everything. The non stick True pan is best for jelly rolls, the 59813 suits big batches, and the rack set is the best value for beginners. Any of these four would improve a home bakery.

If your jelly rolls stick or your cookies brown unevenly, I say try a Chicago Metallic pan and bake your favorite recipe on it. Start with parchment, watch how evenly it browns, and notice how easily the food releases. I bake more confidently now, and my jelly rolls finally roll without cracking. That is a pan worth keeping.

James Turner
James Turner

James Turner is a product researcher and the lead writer at Stopista, where he creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, outdoor gear and personal care. He approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and he is quick to point out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. James is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. His reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making him a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 4791