My Anchor Hocking glass bowls have lasted for years, but their plastic lids cracked, warped, and vanished one by one until I had a shelf of useful bowls I could not store food in. Buying new bowls just for the lids felt wasteful, so I went looking for replacements that fit the bowls I already own. I tested five sets over several weeks, checking fit, seal, and durability on my own bowls. Here is what I found, including the mixed pack that now covers almost every bowl I own. I wanted lids that sealed tightly and survived the dishwasher.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Anchor Hocking Replacement Lids Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Sophico Silicone Storage Cover Lids Replacement for Anchor Hocking and Pyrex Glass Bowls (Container not Included) (MIX-9 PACK)
I picked up the Sophico Silicone Storage Cover Lids Replacement because I had a shelf full of Anchor Hocking bowls with no lids. The nine pack includes a mix of shapes and sizes, and the silicone stretches to fit bowls that are not quite standard. I pressed one onto a two cup bowl and it sealed with a satisfying grip. The lids feel thick and flexible, and the mix of colors makes it easy to tell sizes apart. —Melissa Grant
I have used the Sophico Silicone Storage Cover Lids Replacement daily for a month, and the seal has held on everything from soup to salad. The silicone grips the rim tightly, and I have had no leaks even when a bowl tipped in the fridge. They wash easily by hand or in the dishwasher, and they have not stretched out or torn. My only complaint is that the largest lid is still too small for my biggest mixing bowl. —Andrew Foster
What I liked most about the Sophico Silicone Storage Cover Lids Replacement is the variety in one pack. With nine lids in different sizes and shapes, I almost always find one that fits. The silicone is thick enough to seal well but flexible enough to stretch. If you have a pile of lidless bowls, this is the set I would buy first. It is the set I grab first every time. —Stephanie Reed
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Replacement Wooden Lids for Pyrex, Anchor Hocking Glass Containers, Bamboo Lids for Pyrex Glass Bowls, Bowl Covers with Leakproof Silicone Gasket 1CUP*2+2CUP*3+4CUP*2+7CUP*2
I grabbed the Replacement Wooden Lids for Pyrex because I wanted a sturdier, nicer looking cover for my glass bowls. The bamboo lids come in four sizes with a silicone gasket that seals against the rim, and they look far better on a table than plastic wrap. I set one on a two cup bowl of leftovers, and it sat flat and sealed well. The wood feels smooth, and the gasket keeps the lid from sliding off. —Justin Cole
I have used the Replacement Wooden Lids for Pyrex for serving and storage, and they have held up well. The bamboo does not stain easily, and a quick wipe keeps it clean. The gasket seals tightly enough to keep food fresh overnight, though I would not trust it for a tipped bowl the way I trust silicone. My only note is that the wood should not go in the dishwasher, so hand washing is required. —Hannah Brooks
My honest take on the Replacement Wooden Lids for Pyrex is that they are the prettiest lids in this test. They turn a storage bowl into a serving dish, and the bamboo looks good on the table. They are not the best choice for transport, since the seal is not leakproof, but for fridge storage and serving they are excellent. If looks matter as much as function, this is the set I would choose. —Tyler Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Yodecy Silicone Bowl Lids fit Pyrex Glass Bowls 7200-PC 2 Cup, fit Anchor Hocking Glass Bowls 7200-PC 2 Cup, Replacement Lids 4.76in/12.1cm (4 Pack Pastel Yellow)
I tried the Yodecy Silicone Bowl Lids fit Pyrex Glass Bowls 7200-PC 2 Cup because I needed lids for my two cup Anchor Hocking bowls specifically. The four pack of pastel yellow lids fits the two cup size exactly, with a snug rim that seals without stretching. I pressed one onto a bowl of soup and carried it to work without a single drip. The yellow color is cheerful, and the lids are easy to spot in a drawer. —Olivia Grant
I have used the Yodecy Silicone Bowl Lids fit Pyrex Glass Bowls 7200-PC 2 Cup for lunches and leftovers, and they have been reliable. The silicone is thick, the seal is tight, and the lids have not warped in the dishwasher. They only fit the two cup size, so they are useless for my larger bowls, but for the size they cover they are perfect. My only complaint is that I wish the pack included more sizes. —Nathan Pierce
What stood out with the Yodecy Silicone Bowl Lids fit Pyrex Glass Bowls 7200-PC 2 Cup is the exact fit. A lid made for one size seals better than a stretchy universal lid, and these prove it. The pastel yellow looks nice, and the quality has held up to daily use. If you own a lot of two cup bowls, this is the pack I would buy. The fit is spot on. —Sarah Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Sophico Round Silicone Storage Cover Lids Replacement for Anchor Hocking and Pyrex Glass Bowls (Container not Included) (4 Size, 8 Pack)
I bought the Sophico Round Silicone Storage Cover Lids Replacement because I wanted a simple set of round lids in four sizes. The eight pack includes two of each size, and the silicone stretches to fit a range of bowls. I used one on a mixing bowl and another on a small prep bowl, and both sealed well. The color coded pairs make it easy to grab the right size without measuring. —James Carter
I have used the Sophico Round Silicone Storage Cover Lids Replacement for leftovers and meal prep, and the lids have been dependable. The seal holds through a night in the fridge, and the silicone has not torn or stretched out after dozens of uses. They stack neatly in a drawer, which saves space. My only note is that the smallest size is still a bit large for very small prep bowls. —Emily Rodriguez
My take on the Sophico Round Silicone Storage Cover Lids Replacement is that it is the best straightforward set in this test. Eight lids in four sizes covers most bowls in my kitchen, and the quality is consistent. It is a little less versatile than the mixed shape nine pack, but for round bowls it is perfect. If your bowls are all round, this is the set I would choose. —Michael Thompson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Purekra 4 PCS Silicone Replacement Lids for Pyrex and Anchor Hocking Glass Custard Cups 6oz, Prepware Dessert Cup Cover, Silicone Lids for Food Storage, Dishwasher Safe (Containers NOT Included)
I picked up the Purekra 4 PCS Silicone Replacement Lids because I needed covers for my small six ounce custard cups. The four pack fits Pyrex and Anchor Hocking custard cups exactly, and the silicone seals tightly enough to keep desserts fresh. I used them on individual puddings and custards, and the lids stayed put in the fridge. They are small and simple, but they do the job well. They seal well. —Jessica Lee
I have used the Purekra 4 PCS Silicone Replacement Lids for desserts and small portions, and they have held up well. The silicone is food safe, washes easily, and has not warped in the dishwasher. They only fit the six ounce custard cups, so they are useless for larger bowls, but for their size they are perfect. My only complaint is that four lids is not many if you bake custards often. —David Martinez
My honest take on the Purekra 4 PCS Silicone Replacement Lids is that they are a niche but useful pick. They solve one specific problem well, covering custard cups that are otherwise hard to lid. The quality is good, and the seal is tight. If you own custard cups and hate using plastic wrap, this is the set I would buy. They are small, simple, and they work every time. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Anchor Hocking Replacement Lids Is Necessary
I started looking for replacement lids because my Anchor Hocking bowls outlived their plastic covers years ago. Glass bowls last forever, but lids crack, warp, and disappear, leaving a shelf of useful bowls I could not store food in. Buying new bowls just for lids felt wasteful, so I went looking for replacements that fit the bowls I already own.
A good lid also matters for food safety, since an open bowl in the fridge dries out and picks up odors. I look for a seal that keeps food fresh, a fit that matches my bowl sizes, and a material that survives the dishwasher. A lid that leaks or pops off is worse than no lid, since it gives false confidence.
I have tried plastic wrap, foil, and plates as covers, and none of them work as well as a proper lid. A silicone lid stretches to fit, seals tightly, and washes easily, while a wooden lid looks better on the table. That is why I test both types, comparing seal, fit, and durability across the bowls I actually use.
My Buying Guides on Anchor Hocking Replacement Lids
Why I Looked for Anchor Hocking Replacement Lids
I looked for Anchor Hocking replacement lids after finding a shelf of glass bowls with cracked and missing covers. I wanted lids that fit the bowls I already own, instead of buying new sets. The goal was a tight seal, an easy wash, and a lid for every bowl size I use.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the size first, then the material, then the seal. I measure my bowls and match the lid size to the rim, since a lid that is too small will not seal. I also check whether the lid is dishwasher safe, because a lid I have to hand wash will not get used.
My Preference for Silicone or Wooden Lids
I prefer silicone lids for storage, since they seal tightly and survive the dishwasher. Wooden lids look better for serving and keep food fresh overnight, but they are not leakproof. For the fridge, I reach for silicone first, and I save the wooden lids for the table.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for thick silicone that stretches without tearing, a rim that grips firmly, and a lid that lies flat without curling. I test each lid on my bowls with water to check the seal. A quality lid seals on the first try and keeps its shape after washing.
How I Compare Prices
I compare lids by cost per lid, since packs range from four to nine pieces. I weigh the size range and the material, because a pack that covers more bowls is worth more. A fair cost matches the number of lids and how well they fit.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Measure your bowls before buying, and pick a mixed pack if your bowls vary in size. Choose silicone for leakproof storage and wood for serving. Test the seal with water first, and buy the pack that covers your most used bowl sizes.
Final Thoughts
After testing five sets, the Sophico nine pack is my top pick for most kitchens. It covers many sizes, seals well, and costs a fair amount for nine lids. The wooden lids are the prettiest choice, and the Yodecy pack is perfect if you own mostly two cup bowls. They fit my bowls perfectly every time.
The Sophico eight pack suits round bowls, while the Purekra set is ideal for custard cups. Whichever you choose, measure your bowls first and test the seal before trusting it with soup. A good lid turns a shelf of lidless bowls into useful storage again. A good lid makes every bowl in the cupboard useful again.





