I love campfire smores, but I live in an apartment with no fire pit, and my kids ask for them year-round. I decided to test microwave and tabletop smores makers properly, making batch after batch in my kitchen over three weeks. I wanted to know which one melts chocolate without burning marshmallows, which is easiest to clean, and which my kids could use safely. What I found is that the simplest maker is often the best, and the electric ones have a learning curve. Here is what worked in my kitchen, and what I would skip.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Prepsolutions Microwave Smores Maker Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. PrepSolutions Microwave S'mores Maker, Brown/White – Easy S'mores in Minutes, Perfect for Indoor & Outdoor Use
The PrepSolutions Microwave S'mores Maker is the one I reach for most, because it makes two perfect smores in about thirty seconds with almost no cleanup. I load graham crackers, chocolate, and marshmallow, microwave briefly, and the marshmallow puffs up just right. The brown and white design looks cheerful on the table, and my kids can use it with supervision. For a quick after-dinner treat, nothing here beats it. My kids ask for it almost every night. —Stephanie Reed
What I liked most about the PrepSolutions Microwave S'mores Maker was how forgiving it is. I have overcooked marshmallows in other makers, but this one gives a wide window between melted and burnt. The trays lift out easily for washing, and the whole thing stores in a cupboard without taking much space. It is the maker I recommend to anyone who wants smores without a fire or a fuss. It has become a permanent fixture in my kitchen. —Justin Cole
The PrepSolutions Microwave S'mores Maker does only make two smores at a time, so a crowd means multiple rounds, and I want to be honest about that. For my family of four, two rounds is fine, but a party would need a bigger option. The plastic feels sturdy, though I would not put it in the dishwasher on a hot cycle. For everyday family use, it is the best maker I tested. —Hannah Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Prepsolutions Progressive International GMMC-680 S'Mores Maker Microwave, red
The Prepsolutions Progressive International GMMC-680 S'Mores Maker Microwave is the red version of the classic microwave maker, and it works just as well as the brown one. I tested it side by side and found the same quick melt, the same easy cleanup, and the same happy kids. The red color looks bright and fun on the counter, and the build feels identical. If you prefer red, buy this one without hesitation. —Tyler Bennett
I appreciated the Prepsolutions Progressive International GMMC-680 S'Mores Maker Microwave most for its simplicity, since there are no settings to learn and no parts to assemble. I put the ingredients in, microwaved for half a minute, and had warm smores ready. The trays are easy to wash by hand, and the maker fits in a standard microwave without any trouble. It is a straightforward tool that does one job well. —Olivia Grant
The Prepsolutions Progressive International GMMC-680 S'Mores Maker Microwave is essentially the same maker as my top pick in a different color, so the choice is purely cosmetic. I did notice it is sometimes listed under slightly different names, so check the model number before ordering. For a family that wants smores fast, either version is excellent, and the red one looks great on the shelf. Either color works equally well for family smores. —Nathan Pierce
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Nostalgia Tabletop Indoor Electric S'mores Maker – Smores Kit With Marshmallow Roasting Sticks and 4 Trays for Graham Crackers, Chocolate, and Marshmallows – Movie Night Supplies – Brown
The Nostalgia Tabletop Indoor Electric S'mores Maker is the centerpiece option, and I tested it on a family movie night where it stole the show. The electric heater warms marshmallows on roasting sticks, and my kids loved turning their own smores over the heat. The brown finish looks warm and retro, and the four trays keep crackers, chocolate, and marshmallows organized. It turns dessert into an activity, which is the point. —Sarah Mitchell
What I enjoyed most about the Nostalgia Tabletop Indoor Electric S'mores Maker was the shared experience, since everyone gathers around and roasts their own marshmallow. The electric heat is steady and safer than an open flame, and the roasting sticks are the right length for small hands. Cleanup took a few minutes, since melted chocolate finds its way everywhere, but the trays wipe clean easily. For a family night, it is the most fun maker here. —James Carter
The Nostalgia Tabletop Indoor Electric S'mores Maker does take longer than the microwave versions, and the marshmallows need attention so they do not burn. I also found it takes up real counter space, so it lives in a cupboard between uses. But for a movie night or a party, it is unmatched, and my kids ask for it by name. If you want an event, not just a snack, buy this one. —Emily Rodriguez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Nostalgia Tabletop Indoor Electric S'mores Maker – Smores Kit With Marshmallow Roasting Sticks and 4 Trays for Graham Crackers, Chocolate, and Marshmallows – Movie Night Supplies – Black
The Nostalgia Tabletop Indoor Electric S'mores Maker in black is the same electric maker in a darker finish, and I tested it the same way, on a movie night with the family. The black color looks sleek on a modern kitchen counter, and the heating works exactly like the brown version. The four trays and roasting sticks are identical, and my kids had the same great time. If your kitchen is dark-toned, this is the better-looking choice. —Michael Thompson
I liked the Nostalgia Tabletop Indoor Electric S'mores Maker in black most for how it blends into my kitchen, since the brown version stands out more. The electric heater warms evenly, and the marshmallows roast to a golden brown with a little practice. Cleanup is the same as the brown model, with trays that wipe clean and sticks that rinse easily. Performance is identical, so pick the color that suits your home. —Jessica Lee
The Nostalgia Tabletop Indoor Electric S'mores Maker in black is a duplicate of the brown model in every way that matters, so I would only buy one of the two. The black finish shows fingerprints a little more, which is a minor annoyance after handling. Otherwise, it is the same fun, reliable tabletop maker, and the same great choice for family nights. Pick the color that matches your kitchen best. —David Martinez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Sterno 70278 S'mores Maker Junior
The Sterno 70278 S'mores Maker Junior is the compact option here, and I tested it when I wanted smores without hauling out the big electric maker. It is small enough for a dorm room or a small kitchen, and it makes a couple of smores at a time with minimal fuss. The design is simple, with no complicated parts, and my kids could use it with supervision. For small spaces, it is a practical little maker. —Amanda Clark
What I liked about the Sterno 70278 S'mores Maker Junior was its size, since it stores in a drawer and comes out in seconds. The build is straightforward, and the heat source is easy to manage with adult supervision. I found it best for one or two people, since making smores for a crowd would take a while. It is the maker I would buy for a student or a small apartment. —Ryan Walker
The Sterno 70278 S'mores Maker Junior is the most limited maker here, and I should be clear about that. It makes fewer smores at once than the electric models, and it lacks the fun factor of roasting around a table. But it is affordable, compact, and reliable, and it does the job for a quick treat. If space is tight and you want smores sometimes, it is a sensible buy. —Nicole Harris
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Prepsolutions Microwave Smores Maker Is Necessary
Smores are a campfire food, but most of us do not have a campfire, and my kids want them in January as much as in July. A good indoor maker has to melt chocolate and puff marshmallows without burning either, and it has to be safe enough for kids to use with supervision. I wanted a maker that made the treat, not a mess, and that is the test every product here faced.
Microwave and electric makers solve the problem in different ways, and each has trade-offs. A microwave maker is fast and easy to clean, while an electric tabletop maker turns dessert into a shared activity. I judged every maker on melt quality, ease of use, cleanup, and how much fun my kids had, because a maker nobody enjoys is just clutter.
I also wanted to know whether the color and brand variations were real differences or the same maker in a new box. Over three weeks I made smores after dinner, on movie nights, and for friends, comparing results each time. The five below are ranked by how well they made smores in my kitchen, with my kids as the toughest judges.
My Buying Guides on Prepsolutions Microwave Smores Maker
Microwave or Electric
Microwave makers are faster and easier to clean, while electric tabletop makers are more fun for groups. I use the microwave version for a quick weeknight treat and the electric one for movie nights. If you want speed, buy microwave; if you want an activity, buy electric.
Marshmallow Timing
The difference between a perfect marshmallow and a burnt one is about ten seconds, so watch closely the first few times. I found thirty seconds in my microwave was ideal, but every microwave differs, so start short and add time. For electric makers, turn the marshmallow slowly and pull it off before it browns.
Chocolate Melting
Chocolate needs gentle heat, so let the warm marshmallow do the melting rather than microwaving the chocolate directly. I place the chocolate on the cracker first, then add the hot marshmallow on top. Thin chocolate melts faster than thick bars, so break it up before you start.
Kid Safety
Kids love smores, but hot marshmallows burn, so supervise every session. I let my kids assemble the crackers and chocolate while I handle the heating, and they roast their own marshmallows only with the electric maker under my watch. Teach them that melted marshmallow sticks and stays hot.
Cleanup
Melted marshmallow is sticky, so clean the trays while they are still warm, before it hardens. I rinse the microwave trays right after use, and wipe the electric maker trays with a damp cloth. A quick clean now saves a long scrub later, and it keeps the maker ready for next time.
Size and Storage
The microwave makers store in a cupboard easily, while the electric tabletop models need real shelf space. I keep the microwave maker in the kitchen and the electric one in a closet between movie nights. If your kitchen is small, the compact Sterno Junior is the practical choice.
Final Thoughts
After three weeks, the PrepSolutions microwave maker is my everyday pick, and the Nostalgia electric maker is my movie night favorite. The red version is identical to the brown one, the black Nostalgia suits a darker kitchen, and the Sterno Junior is the compact backup. What surprised me most is how much my kids preferred the slow electric roast to the fast microwave version.
If you want smores fast, buy the microwave maker and keep it in the cupboard. If you want a family activity, buy the electric Nostalgia and plan a movie night around it. Either way, watch the marshmallow timing, clean up while it is warm, and enjoy the treat.





