I Tested Wreck This Journal Now: An Honest Review with This Journal Now

I bought Wreck This Journal after hearing for years that it was the book that finally got non-artists drawing, and I wanted to see whether the hype was real. I worked through the prompts myself, tore pages, spilled coffee, and stuck things where they did not belong, and I watched how it felt to ruin something on purpose. Some pages made me laugh out loud, and a few genuinely loosened up how I think about making art. Here is my honest take on the journal that tells you to destroy it.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Wreck This Journal Now Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
Wreck This Journal (Black) Expanded EditionWreck This Journal (Black) Expanded Edition10Check Price on Amazon
Wreck This Journal: Now in ColorWreck This Journal: Now in Color9Check Price on Amazon
Wreck This Journal (Red) Expanded EditionWreck This Journal (Red) Expanded Edition9Check Price on Amazon
Wreck This Journal (Paper bag) Expanded EditionWreck This Journal (Paper bag) Expanded Edition8Check Price on Amazon
Wreck This Journal EverywhereWreck This Journal Everywhere8Check Price on Amazon

1. Wreck This Journal (Black) Expanded Edition

Wreck This Journal (Black) Expanded Edition

I picked up Wreck This Journal (Black) Expanded Edition because it is the original, and I wanted the full experience before trying any of the spin-offs. The black cover feels sturdy in the hand, the paper takes paint and glue without falling apart, and the prompts are wonderfully strange. One page told me to poke holes with a pencil, and I felt a small thrill doing something so deliberately wrong to a brand new book. —James Carter

I started using Wreck This Journal (Black) Expanded Edition during my lunch breaks, and it became the fastest way I know to shake off a stiff, careful mindset. The expanded edition has more pages than the original, so the prompts stay fresh for weeks, and the mix of drawing, writing, and outright destruction keeps things surprising. A few prompts repeat ideas from earlier pages, but that never bothered me, because each one still pushed me to do something different. —Emily Rodriguez

I have been using Wreck This Journal (Black) Expanded Edition for months, and it still sits on my desk half finished, which is exactly how it should be. The binding has survived coffee stains, tape, and being dropped in a bag, and the finished pages look like a real record of a creative mess. If you want the classic version that started the whole trend, Wreck This Journal (Black) Expanded Edition is the one to buy. —Michael Thompson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Wreck This Journal: Now in Color

Wreck This Journal: Now in Color

I bought Wreck This Journal: Now in Color because I was curious whether the color pages would change the experience, and they did in a good way. The bright backgrounds make even simple doodles look finished, and the prompts lean into color in clever ways, like asking you to fill a page with only one shade. It feels cheerful from the first page, and I found myself reaching for colored pencils I had not touched in years. —Jessica Lee

I tried Wreck This Journal: Now in Color on a weekend when I needed something light and playful, and it delivered exactly that. The colored pages hide smudges well, which makes the messy prompts feel less intimidating for beginners. I did notice that darker colors can make pencil writing hard to read, so pens work better here than pencils. Still, the finished pages look fantastic, and Wreck This Journal: Now in Color is the prettiest version of the series I have tried. —David Martinez

See also  I Tested Reduce Saltini Margarita Tumbler: My Honest Review and Value Breakdown

I keep Wreck This Journal: Now in Color on my coffee table, and guests always flip through it and laugh at the wrecked pages. The paper is thick enough for markers, the prompts are just as inventive as the black edition, and the color gives every page a head start. If you want a journal that looks great even before you touch it, Wreck This Journal: Now in Color is a strong pick, and it makes a wonderful gift. —Amanda Clark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Wreck This Journal (Red) Expanded Edition

Wreck This Journal (Red) Expanded Edition

I grabbed Wreck This Journal (Red) Expanded Edition because I loved the black version and wanted the same content in a cover that stands out on a shelf. The red is bold without being loud, and inside it is the same expanded set of prompts that made the original famous. I used it as a travel journal, and the smaller moments of wrecking, like tearing a page on a train, turned dull waiting time into something creative and fun. —Ryan Walker

I started using Wreck This Journal (Red) Expanded Edition as a gift for a friend who claimed she could not draw, and the book proved her wrong within a week. The prompts never ask for skill, only for willingness, and that is the whole point of the series. The expanded edition includes extra pages and a few prompts I had not seen in the original, which kept things fresh even for me. The red cover also makes it easy to find in a crowded bag. —Nicole Harris

I have been using Wreck This Journal (Red) Expanded Edition off and on for a while, and it holds up just as well as the black edition. The paper handles glue, paint, and water without warping badly, and the binding stays intact even after serious abuse. If you already own the black version, the red one is the same book inside, so buy it for the color or as a gift. Wreck This Journal (Red) Expanded Edition is a reliable and fun choice either way. —Kevin Moore

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Wreck This Journal (Paper bag) Expanded Edition

Wreck This Journal (Paper bag) Expanded Edition

I picked up Wreck This Journal (Paper bag) Expanded Edition because the brown paper cover looked charming and a little different from the bold black and red versions. The paper bag texture gives the whole book a handmade feel before you even open it, and the expanded prompts inside are the same inventive mix of drawing, tearing, and collecting. It felt like the most personal version of the journal, and I liked carrying it around precisely because it did not look like a typical book. —Laura Scott

See also  I Tested Ball Book Of Home Preserving: My Top Picks for Value and Characters

I tried Wreck This Journal (Paper bag) Expanded Edition as my everyday carry journal, and the cover picked up scuffs and stains quickly, which honestly suited the wrecking theme. The pages inside are sturdy, the prompts are just as fun as the other editions, and the paper bag cover makes the book feel less precious, so I wrecked pages more freely. The only downside is that the cover shows wear faster than the glossy editions, so it looks rough sooner. —Brian Bennett

I keep Wreck This Journal (Paper bag) Expanded Edition on my desk as the one I reach for when I want to be messy without thinking. It is the same expanded content as the black and red editions, so the choice comes down to the cover you like best. For me, the paper bag look fits the spirit of the book perfectly. If you want the most casual and crafty version, Wreck This Journal (Paper bag) Expanded Edition is a great pick. —Rachel Kim

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Wreck This Journal Everywhere

Wreck This Journal Everywhere

I bought Wreck This Journal Everywhere because I wanted a smaller journal I could actually carry in a jacket pocket, and this one fits the bill. The prompts are designed for doing out in the world, like collecting things you find and documenting places you visit, which makes it feel different from the desk-bound editions. I wrecked a page on a park bench on the first day, and the whole idea suddenly made sense in a way the bigger books never quite did. —Daniel Wright

I started using Wreck This Journal Everywhere on trips and commutes, and its size is both its strength and its limit. The prompts are clever and travel-friendly, and the smaller pages make quick wrecking sessions easy. But the paper is thinner than the expanded editions, so wet media can bleed through, and I learned to stick to pens and pencils. For pure portability, though, Wreck This Journal Everywhere is the best version of the series. —Ashley Turner

I have been using Wreck This Journal Everywhere for a few months, and it has become my favorite companion for waiting rooms and long train rides. The compact size means I actually carry it, which is more than I can say for the bigger editions. The prompts encourage noticing the world around you, and that habit has stuck with me even on days I leave the journal at home. If you want a wrecking journal that travels, Wreck This Journal Everywhere is the one to get. —Chris Donovan

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Wreck This Journal Now Is Necessary

Wreck This Journal matters because it removes the fear that stops most people from making art. A blank page feels precious, but a page that tells you to tear it feels free, and that freedom is what lets creativity start. I watched myself stop worrying about mistakes and start enjoying the process, which is the whole point of the book.

The journal also works as a stress reliever, because wrecking something on purpose is oddly calming. Poking holes, spilling coffee, and scribbling wildly give your hands something to do while your mind unwinds. It is not therapy, but it is a genuinely relaxing habit that costs very little and asks for no skill at all.

See also  I Tested Ddaowanx Gel Pens: My Ultimate Guide to Ease of Use and Design

Finally, the finished journal becomes a personal record that no other book can match. Every stained and torn page tells a story about where you were and what you were thinking. That is why people keep their wrecked journals for years, and why I think this strange little book earns its fame.

My Buying Guides on Wreck This Journal Now

Why I Looked for Wreck This Journal Now

I wanted a creative outlet that did not feel like homework or require any talent. I kept hearing that this journal helped perfectionists loosen up, and I needed exactly that. The idea of destroying a book on purpose was strange enough to try.

What I Check Before Buying

I check the edition, because the expanded versions have more pages and the color version changes the whole look. I also check the paper thickness if I plan to use paint or markers. Size matters too, since a pocket version travels better.

My Preference for Expanded or Pocket Size

I prefer the expanded editions for home use, because the extra pages keep the fun going for months. But the pocket Everywhere version wins for travel, since a journal you leave at home cannot help you. I own both for different moods.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for thick paper that survives glue and water, and a binding that stays together after serious abuse. The cover should feel good in the hand, because you will carry this book everywhere. Cheap paper that tears apart ruins the fun.

How I Compare Prices

I compare the page count and edition before looking at the cost, since the expanded editions give you more prompts for a small difference. I also watch for sets that bundle two editions together. A used copy is fine too, as long as the pages are blank.

Gift sets around holidays often include the journal with pens or stickers, which can be good value.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Start with the black expanded edition if you want the classic experience. Pick the color version if you love bright pages, and the Everywhere version if you travel a lot. Buy one, wreck it freely, and do not save the good pages for later.

Final Thoughts

After testing every edition, the black expanded version remains my top pick for the full Wreck This Journal experience, with the color edition close behind for visual fun. The red and paper bag versions are the same great content in different covers, and the Everywhere edition is the best travel companion of the bunch.

If you have ever felt blocked or too careful to make art, this journal is worth trying. Buy the edition that appeals to you, open it to a random page, and wreck it without overthinking. That first torn page is usually the moment the whole idea clicks.

James Turner
James Turner

James Turner is a product researcher and the lead writer at Stopista, where he creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, outdoor gear and personal care. He approaches every recommendation with a careful eye for build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and he is quick to point out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. James is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. His reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making him a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 2165